Comments on: Top 5 green hatchbacks and superminis

By: Tom R

Tom R — Sun, 12 Jun 2011 21:13:47 +0000

Unfortunately I need a car, although I use one as little as possible. I’d like as green a car as I can find, and I don’t want a large car. But manufacturers forget that not everyone is of a standard size. I can’t help the fact I have long legs.
I’ve only tried out 3 cars on the list so far and cannot fit in a VW Polo or any model of Toyota. I can fit in the Seat Ibiza, and hopefully at least one of the others listed.
Currently I have a yr 2000 Skoda Fabia TDi which still does a decent mpg (c.50mpg) but I can’t fit in the new design of Skoda Fabia. I’m a single person so have no use of a large car.

By: Mark Ch

Mark Ch — Tue, 17 May 2011 13:08:19 +0000

I have a Smartfortwo and it is great, cannot see anything coming out of exhaust and it goes miles and miles to the gallon and its fun to drive.
The sooner we all have a car with CO2 as low as mine the better the world will be, get these large cars off the road. And get lorrys off the road and get frieght back on rail.

By: Andyj

Andyj — Fri, 17 Dec 2010 13:57:38 +0000

Rick is correct about CO2 and soot etc. which is great for plant life. The oil emissions against yearly climate CO2 change rates shows oil is not even a player in the game of the Earth. Deforestation is another matter. which brings me to the only player in the game.

Proximity of engines per volume of air and population size.

Diesels consume 38% less than a car engine generating the same power.

Car fumes are noxious.
Diesel fumes are obnoxious.

Everything a diesel lets off is readily eaten off by plant matter and ultra violet light. Not so with car exhaust fumes.

So you say car fumes smell a lot less. When Iran and Iraq were nerve gassing each other, The victims smelt……….. Nothing.

More than 1 in 2.5 die of cancer. Find the facts and enjoy the rest of your days.

By: Rick

Rick — Wed, 26 May 2010 09:31:39 +0000

This “top 5″ is based purely on CO2 emissions, which is slightly disingenuous. Diesels are not so bad these days, but their emissions are so much more than just CO2. They emit soot, NOX and other nasties that petrols do not. Cycle along a road with lots of diesels, and you get a noseful of this filth, even with modern cars.

The fact they get good mpg is down to the fact that diesel is more energy-dense than petrol. It doesn’t make it more “green”.

Regarding the comment about “why are there no automatics?”

That’s because automatics generally suck! Just compare the CO2 ratings for the auto and non-auto IQ. There is a 10% difference in efficiency. Not to mention the fact they are slower and unpleasant to drive.

By: Andyj

Andyj — Mon, 01 Feb 2010 16:28:23 +0000

The reason why diesels do more to the gallon is very simple. They are more efficient. Petrol cars have an apparently nicer exhaust but the gases are far more insidious.
The catalytic convertor is to burn off (break down) any unburnt fuel. They always shove in too much fuel to keep the exhaust valves from burning up.

Whats this about diesels being noisy? Stand on the side of some ‘A’ road and I’ll challenge anyone to tell if a car going down the road is petrol or not. The tyre noise is always well above any engine.

By: Manny

Manny — Thu, 14 Jan 2010 11:17:18 +0000

Most of you guys are on here are a bit simple. Diesels have always had cleaner emissions than petrols. That’s why four of the five cars here are diesel, it’s no scam it’s logic. You are probably from the era when diesels were un-refined and smelly i.e. Peugeot 304, Mercedes 240D etc.

By: Smog Buster

Smog Buster — Fri, 11 Dec 2009 09:22:56 +0000

The Smart is a very uncomfortable ‘car’ and by having only 2 seats is compromised is every way – it is just a gimmick car to get Mercedes Benz’s CO2 emissions down. Agree on the diesel comments, they emit a whole raft of nasties that petrols don’t. I have driven an iQ and it is fantastic – 99g/km is amazing and the car feels like a premium C segment product (A3, 1 series etc).

By: David Smith

David Smith — Thu, 03 Sep 2009 16:28:56 +0000

If you believe in the AGW scam and class low C02 as green then the diesels are great. If you think, like me, that a diesel chugs out filth that irritates your lungs no matter its engine condition, then the IQ is the only green car on the list.

By: Gerard Huke

Gerard Huke — Tue, 25 Aug 2009 16:51:39 +0000

All Smarts are automatics, I drove the Smart Fortwo cdi yesterday along with the Fiesta Eco-netic – the Smart is £4k cheaper

By: Scott

Scott — Mon, 08 Jun 2009 08:30:17 +0000

Like Steve, I don’t like diesels and the Toyota iQ is not a diesel. I quote: “Available in the UK as petrol-only, the iQ debuts the new carbon dioxide-cutting technology that squeezes emissions below 100g/km, making the iQ road-tax free – unheard of for a petrol. I have no connection with Toyota neither do I have an iQ as I doubt they will be included in the ‘scrappage’ scheme!