SaveMoneyOnCars.co.uk
Subscribe to RSS feed. Follow us on Twitter.

Search

Poll

Can advanced non-food source biofuels offer a truly environmentally-friendly fuel solution?

Newsletter

Receive the latest news direct to your Inbox! Simply enter your email address below to sign up for our weekly newsletter.
Privacy Policy

UK Aware 2010
GreenFleet Award

News Categories

Show categories | Hide categories

Archive

Show archives | Hide archives

Pages

Show pages | Hide pages

Meta

Do electric cars need cowbells?

There have been some unusual suggestions as to how to counter the fact that electric cars have quiet engines over the years – but perhaps this one is the most amusing yet.

Lord McColl, a Conservative peer, has suggested that electric cars be fitted with a small Swiss cowbell to warn pedestrians they are approaching. The peer, who is also a party health spokesman, raised the issue with Lord Adonis, the Transport Secretary, in the House of Lords earlier this month.

Though the picture of a car with a cowbell may be amusing, it is meant to address a serious issue – that of pedestrian safety. Lord McColl is also said to be concerned about the lack of engine noise from hybrid cars such as the Toyota Prius, which form a substantial part of the Government’s ministerial fleet.

He commented that when purchasing one of these cars a few years ago his wife suggested the idea of a small Swiss cowbell. McColl said he was only speaking half in jest – as an owner of a Prius he said people can’t always hear it coming and a little cowbell might do the trick.

Lord Grenfell, a Labour peer, proposed an even more radical solution suggesting a man with a red flag should walk in front of the car. The use of a man with a red flag ceased to be compulsory in 1896, when the speed limit was raised from four to 20mph.

Though that suggestion appears to be tongue in cheek, the Government is said to be examining the potential dangers to blind pedestrians in particular from electric and hybrid cars, but Lord Adonis stated that he does not believe either suggestion would work in 21st Century Britain.

Author: Paul Lucas, November 22, 2009
Filed under: Electric cars, Green cars, Latest news

3 Comments »

They have been looking at this issue for a while in Japan and the USA, specifically in connection with the visually impaired, but as electric cars become more prevailent it is an issue for all pedestrians as we rely as much on hearing cars as seeing them.

It’s quite ironic given that manufacturers have spent years trying to make cars as noiseless as possible. Basically they are trying to think how they can bring back some noise.

Some engineers working on the Nissan Leaf specifically (http://www.electriccarsite.co.uk/nissan-leaf-electric-car#comment-31363) have recently been presenting some ideas for artificial noises, chimes, a melody, a vroooom.

It will be interesting to see what they come up……

Comment by ally — November 22, 2009 @ 10:58 am

In this age of sensors, one fitted to a car that reacts to (close)moving objects or objects in the way that will activate a sound and/or brakes isn’t too difficult to envisage.
Uniformity on the nature of the sound so pedestrians recognise it for what is represents will prove the most difficult part.
To beep or not to beep THAT is the question.

Comment by Peter O'Connor — November 24, 2009 @ 5:57 pm

Electric cars are progressing really quickly now and in my opinion they’ll be rivalling petrol and diesel cars shortly.

Comment by ford rs auctions — March 15, 2010 @ 12:00 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

On the forum...

Latest from ContractHireAndLeasing.com

Latest from FleetDirectory.co.uk

ETA - Join the drive for greener motoring