Tuesday 31 August 2010: The Green Piece Column.
It’s one of the most common concerns about the electrification of the automobile – no, not how long the range of these vehicles will last or how regularly batteries will need to be replaced; but just how safe are electric cars?
Electrical fires are notoriously dangerous, particularly for fire-fighters using water or other conductive agents. Over the years, electrical shocks have caused many deaths and though solutions have been found – fire-fighters generally use dry chemical powder extinguishers and carbon dioxide to put out electrical fires – there are fears that a surge in electrical vehicle numbers could exacerbate the problem.
However, General Motors attempted to address this issue with a nationwide electric vehicle training tour in the US.
Inspired by the Volt
A pre-production version of the Chevrolet Volt (to be known in the UK as the Vauxhall Ampera) was used as a teaching tool on the tour which included classroom training and a live extrication exercise in which fire-fighters practised door and roof removal.
As part of the exercise, fire-fighters inspected the instrument panel to ensure that the crashed Chevrolet Volt had been turned off. They were then able to stabilise the vehicle with a “chock and block” procedure before deflating the Volt’s tyres to ensure it remained stable during cutting and extrication. The 12V electrical system is then disabled by cutting the battery cables at designated cut points behind a trim panel towards the rear of the car.
The Volt does come with a removable high voltage service plug in the rear centre console which can be used to disable high voltage components. However, this is mainly designed for automotive technicians and could be difficult to access at the scene of an accident.
Steps towards safety
The good news for fire-fighters and the emergency services in general is that the issue of safety is being looked at very carefully by General Motors and other car manufacturers.
The Volt, for example, comes with an on-board safety system. This automatically unlocks its doors and activates emergency flashes while disabling the fuel pump when an airbag signal is detected.
The lithium-ion battery pack meanwhile is bolted to the underside of the vehicle floor from underneath. It has been subjected to an array of abuse tests including overcharge, discharge, vibration, excess heat and cold, short circuit, humidity, fire and more. GM actually recommends that a Volt battery fire can be fought with water rather than dry chemicals as the Volt battery has no explosion or electrocution hazard as the result of a collision. The high voltage system shuts down automatically as soon as airbags are deployed.
In the US, the Volt is also supported by OnStar safety. This means that first responders will be informed that the Volt features an electric powertrain before they arrive on the scene.
Thanks to the OnStar application, the vehicle’s position can be triangulated to determine if it has left the roadway and the advisers can sound the vehicle’s horn to help personnel locate the vehicle. OnStar has also developed an Impact Severity Predictor that evaluates the intensity and angle of impact and predicts the likelihood of injuries in the vehicle.
Potential problems
One area that did cause some issues for the fire-fighters during the challenge was the inability to cut through ultra high strength steel such as boron or martensite.
This structural steel was first used in Volvo vehicles in the late 1990s and has since become commonplace throughout the industry. It is seen as an important safety feature because it can enhance side impact protection and roof strength integrity.
Indeed more than 70 per cent of the Volt’s structural steel uses ultra high strength steel, including the floor which supports the battery pack. The problem of course is that cutting through this sort of material with an electric battery close by can be dangerous due to the sparking from the high-speed rotary cut-off saws, which present a fire hazard. Indeed the jaws of older hydraulic cutting tools can spread from excessive side loads when a cut is attempted. However, most extrication tools have been upgraded to deal with the new steels.
Our verdict on the safety of electric cars
It’s understandable that new car buyers would have their doubts about the safety of electric cars and the ability of first responders to deal with a crash scene and fire involving an electric powertrain.
However, as with any new technology it’s safe to assume that as electric cars become more commonplace, fire-fighters will be better equipped to deal with emergencies. Most importantly for early electric car buyers, manufacturers are taking the safety issue very seriously, and, just as General Motors is doing with the Volt, are implementing unique safety features that should make drivers just as comfortable in an electric powered car as they are in a regular vehicle.
With time it may even be the case that electric cars are safer than their petrol and diesel counterparts because the implementation of Smart Grid technology should increase vehicle communications making responses to accidents faster and more efficient. Yes there may be teething problems, but electric cars have come a long way and so has their commitment to safety.
Faye Sunderland
Share on Facebook